Dog Toy Safety: Simple Tips for Choosing Safer Dog Toys

Choose toys that are genuinely safe for your dog's size and chewing style — and learn which popular toys to avoid.

The Size Rule

Every toy must be too large to fit entirely in your dog's mouth. A toy that fits completely in the mouth can be lodged in the throat or swallowed.

Hardness Rule

If you cannot dent it with your thumbnail, it is too hard. Hard items fracture teeth. Avoid: real bones, antlers, hooves, hard nylon, ice cubes.

Toys to Avoid

Known Hazards: Button eyes on stuffed toys (swallowed), squeakers in easily destroyed toys (choking hazard once exposed), rope toys for power chewers (fibers cause intestinal damage), tennis balls for power chewers (fuzzy surface damages teeth, pieces swallowable), toys with strings or elastic.

Safest Options

  • Rubber chew toys (Kong, West Paw Zogoflex)
  • Food puzzle toys
  • Tug toys (with reliable drop-it cue)
  • Size-appropriate rubber fetch toys